The last time Hackerfall tried to access this page, it returned a not found error. A cached version of the page is below, or clickhereto continue anyway

-no-cpp-precomp: The Compiler Flag That Time Forgot - The Future Is Now

Im often surprised how long software can keep trying to use compatibility features ages after their best-by date.

Now that GCC 4.8 builds on Tiger1, Ive been testing as much software with it as I can. When building ncurses using GCC 4.8.1, though, I came across a strange error message:

gcc-4.8: error: unrecognized command line option ‘-no-cpp-precomp’

It built fine with the gcc-4.0 that came with the OS. GCC rarely removes support for flags like this, so I assumed it must be an Apple-only flag. Unfortunately, it wasnt listed in the manpage at all, and the internet was no help either the search results were full of users confused about the same build failures, or trying to figure out what it does. All I could find was confirmation that its an obsolete Apple-only flag.

Not finding anything, I decided to find out straight from the horses mouth and try source-diving. Luckily Apple publishes the source code for all obsolete versions of their tools at their Apple Open Source site.

Recent versions of Apple GCC dont include the flag anywhere in their source. The only place its still referenced is in a few configure scripts and changelogs, such as these:

# The spiffy cpp-precomp chokes on some legitimate constructs in GCC
# sources; use -no-cpp-precomp to get to GNU cpp.
# Apple's GCC has bugs in designated initializer handling, so disable
# that too.
stage1_cflags="-g -no-cpp-precomp -DHAVE_DESIGNATED_INITIALIZERS=0"

In several releases prior to that, for instance gcc-5493, the flag is explicitly mentioned as being retained for compatibility and is a no-op:

/* APPLE LOCAL cpp-precomp compatibility */
%{precomp:%ecpp-precomp not supported}%{no-cpp-precomp:}%{Wno-precomp:}\

The last time it was actually documented was in gcc-1765’s install.texi, shipped as a part of the WWDC 2004 Developer Preview of Xcode, which also provides a hint as to what the flag actually did:

Its a good idea to use the GNU preprocessor instead of Apples @file{cpp-precomp} during the first stage of bootstrapping; this is automatic when doing @samp{make bootstrap}, but to do it from the toplevel objdir you will need to say @samp{make CC=cc -no-cpp-precomp bootstrap}.

So this partially answers our question: Apple shipped an alternate preprocessor, and -no-cpp-precomp triggers the use of the GCC cpp instead. I can only assume this was a leftover that had yet to be excised, because the flag itself was still a no-op at that time. To actually find a version where the flag does something, we have to go all the way back to the December 2002 developer tools, whose gcc-937.2 actually has code that uses the flag. This particular build of GCC is Apples version of gcc-2.95, and it appears to be the very last where it had any effect. Interestingly, the #ifdef that guards this particular block of code is #ifdef NEXT_CPP_PRECOMP suggesting that this dates back to NeXT, rather than Apple.

To actually find out what this means, OReillys Mac OS X for Unix Geeks, from September 2002, has a nice explanation in chapter 5:

Precompiled header files are binary files that have been generated from ordinary C header files and that have been preprocessed and parsed using cpp-precomp. When such a precompiled header is created, both macros and declarations present in the corresponding ordinary header file are sorted, resulting in a faster compile time, a reduced symbol table size, and consequently, faster lookup. Precompiled header files are given a .p extension and are produced from ordinary header files that end with a .h extension.

Chapter 4 also provides a nice explanation of why -no-cpp-precomp was desirable:

cpp-precomp is faster than cpp. However, some code may not compile with cpp-precomp. In that case, you should invoke cpp by instructing cc not to use cpp-precomp.

So there we have it -no-cpp-precomp became somewhat widely used in Unix software as a compatibility measure to prevent Apples cpp-precomp feature from breaking their headers, and has stuck around more than a decade since the last time its actually done anything.

Continue reading on